Wednesday, May 12, 2010

Upstairs Room Week 2

62 comments:

emma said...

this book is interesting

Maddie said...

It is so sad that the mom died. I wonder what annie is thinking about the war and about her family.

Jaliyah Friend said...

This book is really good. I love hearing about World War 2 now. I dont know how I would feel if I had to live in a cave for 24 hours though. Also I dont knoe how I could go on the train alone without my parents. I really like this book a lot!!

Maddie said...

What house is Rachel and The Father staying at??

Jaliyah said...

I think she is really sad but I think she doesnt want to show it Maddie

kyle elderkin said... said...

Thr book so far is back and forth. If it was modern day I would have stayed with my dieing mother. I dont get why the left the hanninks. I like all the action when she was on the bus, but not all the boring stuff at peoples houses. But sofar I give the book a three an a half star.

Jenna J.:) said...

Okay so so far I kinda like this book.it's alright.If I was Annie I would like to be in the room upstairs at Mr. Hannick's house.I wouldn't want to be in the cave because it would be dark and you wouldn't know what's going on.I would like to be in the room upstairs becuase you can look out the window, see whats happening, etc. I also wouldn't like to be at the farmer's house because it would be really weird to have to sleep with the old man and the girl.I'd only like to sleep with like my sister or like family member not someone i just met.But do you think they took Rachel?I do, or I think she might have died!;(

Jaliyah said...

I really dont know what house they are staying.

Maddie said...

I love this book so much!!!!! It is sooooooo good. I wonder, what is going to happen when the german's come for a house search??

Maddie said...

kyle: they left the hanninks because it wasn't safe for them at that house!

Jenna:) said...

Maddie the father is by himself at a house and Rachel never left. I think she was either taken or she's dead

Emma Wittkowski said...

I think this book is very interesting! World War 2 seems very scary and i don't if i would even be as brave as Annie, When she went on the train alone she was very brave to lie to the solder and say her clothing was for her aunt.It was very sad when the mom died but i wounder were her dad and rachel are?

kyle e. said...

the germans will probably take sini but annie gets away.

Jaliyah Friend said...

I hope she didnt die though Jenna

kyle E. said...

thank you maddie for telling me that.

Jenna:) said...

Maddie:
no that's not why they left the house.
Mr.Hannick had to drop a Jew off and he was on his bike. ON his way home he said he thought he was followed by a German siolder. So he wanted to move Sini and Annie to a different house for a week or 2 just incase so he wouldn't get caught.

Maddie said...

Isn't Rachel staying 40 miles away from where Sini and Annie are staying? And isn't the Father staying at the Hemme's?

Jaliyah said...

I wouldnt be as brave as any of them.

kyle E. said...

rachel is a goner, mother died she is next the there father.

Jenna J. :) said...

JALIYAH:
me too!Rachel is really nice and I hope she didn't die but i think she did!;(

Emma Wittkowski said...

i think she should have stayed at the Hannikens house instead of a dark cave, it would have been even scaryer in a cave than the nice house.

Jenna J. :) said...

KYLE:
wait what about Rachel and the father?
That didn't make sense

Jaliyah said...

Emma: But what if the soilders come then what would they do??d

kyle E. said...

but beeing traped in the house for five months is torcher

Maddie said...

kyle: how do you know that rachel either got caught or died? did you read ahead?

Emma W. said...

Rachel is probibly dead though becuse she shouldnt have stayed

Jenna J. :) said...

KYLE:
I agree with you.Im not sure but I think that the Germans will probably take Sini will probably escape somehow

Emma W. said...

Jaliyah: so caves are creepy the solders might be creepers and search for them in the cave or somthing...

Jenna J. :) said...

KYLE:
They were only in the room upstairs for 2 months then in the cave for 24 hours and now they should be at the farm for 1 to 2 weeks

Maddie said...

i wonder what is going to happen next?!?!

Jaliyah said...

I HOPE she isnt died.

Jaliyah said...

I HOPE she isnt died.

kyle E. said...

genna:
rachel and then there father are next on the death train. Why doesnt Rachel stay with annie an siny.

Emma W., said...

nevermind, I gusse it was safer in the cave than the house but how dose she get food and water?

Jenna J. :) said...

JALIYAH:
What do you think will happen to Rachel and the Father?Do you think Rachel is dead or not?I mean i get you DONT want her to die because either do i but.....

kyle E. said...

Genna:
wonse they get back it might be a nother 3 to 4 months upstairs.

Jaliyah said...

I wonder whats going to happen next to. Maddie

Maddie said...

The dad is at the hemme's and Rachel is 40 miles away. annie and sini are at the oostervald's house. first annie and sini were at the Hannink's house then they had to go to the oostervald's house which is on a farm. the mother died, i wonder does the grandmother know that the mother died??

Emma w said...

Oh their at the farm ok i forgot about the farm so they are safe

kyle E. said...

the grany probably knows

Emma W said...

This book is confusing, so many things happen at once!

Jenna J.:) said...

KYLE:
you spelled my name wrong!!!!!
but anyways Rachel didn't leave at first because she wanted to stay and take care of mother but now that mother's dead Annie and Sini don't know where she is because she never came so.....

Jaliyah said...

Genna:I think the father is going to end up in a camp and i think Rachel is either dead or she is living with someone that we dont know about yet.

Jenna J. :) said...

JALIYAH:
Who's Maddie?
There's no Maddie in the book....

Maddie said...

kyle you spelled granny wrong you spelled it like this : grany!!

kyle E. said...

they are safe anless the germans come looking for hidden jews like themselves. then the are in way over there head. for all we know germans cood be hunting them down right know.

Emma w. said...

I think Rachel and the Dad are dead or in a camp

Maddie said...

this book is kind of confusing emma! and sooo many things happen at once like emma said.

Jaliyah said...

I was talking to Maddie in are group Genna

JENNA! said...

JENNA!!!!!IS MY NAME PEOPLE!

kyle E. said...

every one let my tell you I am not good at spelling so dont yell at me OK!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

JeNnA:) said...

EMMA:
I don't really think the dad is dead but I kinda think that Rachel is

Maddie McClure said...

I wonder why sini and annie have been staying at the farm for like 2 MONTHS INSTEAD OF WEEKS??!?!?!!?

Jaliyah said...

What do you guys think is g oin to happen next.

Jenna:) said...

MADDIE:
What are you talking about Maddie?Annie and Sini haven't been at the farm for 2 months?They've been there for lik 3days or less.

Jenna said...

They're not nessisarily safe because they're at the farm. They could still be caught at any second

kyle E. said...

Lrt me tell all you what i think. First they sould be able to run aroun the house. annie is a kid and sini deserves more freedom. they are growing and you cant grow up stuck inside a farm or up stairs room.

Jaliyah said...

So do you guys like the book or not.

Maddie McClure said...

guys jenna's name is spelled like this: Jenna not genna!

Jenna:D said...

haha thanks Maddie!:)

Maddie said...

see ya

JEnna:) said...

Bi Bi Guys:)
Thanks for Blogging with me!:D