Monday, May 3, 2010

Upstairs Room Week 1

40 comments:

Jenna:) said...

In this book i think it's pretty good. at first i was kinda confused but then i started to get it.i think the mom was a little unwilling and unreasonable when she wouldnt go to america but i see why she said know. it was really sad when she was in the hopsptal but i think they should have taken her.Do u think it was smart of Rachel to stay at the house and not go into hidding?It was really nice of her in my oppinion but it seams like it was very unsafe for her

Jenna:) said...

oops by the way i meant why she said NO not KNOW.oops sry!

Jenna:) said...

oops i meant NO wen i said why she said KNOW. i meant NO!!!sorry!

Jaliyah Friend said...

I think this book is really good. I love hearing about the Civil War but I dont like hearing about how bad they treated the Jews. How would you feel if you were a Jew and you were treated badly? I wouldnt like it at all cause it would make me feel really bad and like noone likes me. But I dont get why Hitler didnt like the Jews they never did anything worng.

Jenna:) said...

I hope this works!its n ot working this is just a test for me real qiuck

maddie said...

I think this book is really good. I think it wasn't very smart of rachel to stay behind and not go into hiding. In the beginning I thought that the mom should have gone to america. it was really sad that she kept having bad headaches. I wonder, what is going to happen to the mom? I feel bad for annie because she doesn't understand what's going on. I think Sini is being really nice to annie. I wonder, If Rachel is going to be in a house close by? them

Emma Wittkowski said...

I think this book is very interesting. When i started reading it it was weird but it got better as i read. I thought when Annie had to go into hidding it would be scary and i probibly wouldnt have remembered her cover name. I think the mom gets a little too angry but when she went to the hospital i gusse it was sad. What do you think will happen to Annie and her family? Do you think Rachel might get caught?

maddie said...

they have to wear the stars because it is part of their culture.

kyle said...

its good but it need some more action to make it a good thriller.

Jaliyah;) said...

I wonder why Hitler hated the Jews to Kyle. Also i would hate living in that time period. If i was the mom i would want to got to america for my kids and for my health. But it might end up being the right desion.

kyle said...

i thought the nazies made them were them to show they are jews

Jenna:) said...

KYLE:
I think they had to waer the stars bcause HItler wanted the Jews to stand out.They discluded them, killed them etc. and they had 2 kno who were jews

also yah i would hate 4 my mom 2 b in the hospital and that sick!!1;(

Emma Wittkowski said...

I wounder why they had to wear stars? Why did the Germans hate the Jews so much? i think this would be a scary place and time to live. yaaa so gusse the book is pretty good :)

Jenna:) said...

maddie the stars arn't part of their culture. I mean the holy star is but HItler made t hem wear the stars

kyle said...

well jalya she cant go she is to sick

emma wittkowski said...

ohh thats why they wore stars kk

Jaliyah Friend said...

But did you have to wear the stars??

kyle said...

all this scrolling up and down to make a coment hurts my arm.

emma wittkowski said...

Rachel must be brave....She should have left the mom should have too

Jenna:) said...

I have no idea why HItler hated the Jews.obviously something was wrong with him in the head but i guess no one really realized it and people had to work for him or they would die.Im a Christian so if i was alive during that time it would affect me but i would deffinitly do all i could do to help the Jew bcuz i think it's wrong.

kyle said...

yes you had to

maddie said...

i wonder what will happen to the dad??

emma wwiittttkkoowwsskkii said...

huh, ok so i dont know what else to ask....so what happend to the mom? why did she go to the hospital i dont get this book

Jenna:) said...

Jaliyah read my comment and others on why they have to wear stars we already discussed this!

JEnna:) said...

my arm hurts 2 kyle:D

emma wittkowski said...

ya were is the dad?

Jaliyah said...

I would HATE living in that time period though.

kyle 1234567 said...

she is about to die and went to the docter cause of her head ackes

Jenna:) said...

i also wonder what will happen to the dad. IN my opinion hes kinda mean!I mean he just goes on his own and goes o wait i guess ill find u kids a hiudding place to.I mean at first he like didnt even care abbout them it seems like.I would have at least stayed and him with my own children!

emma wittkowski said...

does anyone know were the dad is, you people are confusing. so Annie must be scared becuse i could never leave my family i would be to worried

maddie said...

emma, the mom went to the hospital because she kept getting really bad headaches. that is why she went to the hospital

maddie said...

emma, the mom went to the hospital because she kept getting really bad headaches. that is why she went to the hospital

kyle 1234567 said...

but how can the dad trust all of his kids to get were they need to go?

Jaliyah Friend said...

How didnt they know what was going on in the camps

emma wittkowski said...

why would you go to the docter for a head ache weird so hitler must have issues because the people dont even have a job how did they afford a new house??

kyle 1234567 said...

after the war news and other people found out and told all the people of the world

maddie said...

bye

emma wittkowski said...

im glad i didnt go to that creeper camp i would be scaredddd all im saying is that this is scarry creepy and hitler has issues

emma said...

bye

Jenna:) said...

The mom had like kidney or colon problems which gave her massive headeaches.The headaches got so bad and she got really sick so she had 2 go 2 the hospital.Now she's so sick that she's going 2 die;(