Monday, May 3, 2010

Devil's Arithmetic

23 comments:

Mrs. Smith said...

This is how you post a comment.

Sam said...

So far how do you guys like this book? I kinda like it but its kinda boring so far. I think it will probly get better though. I thought Hannah handled the problem with her mom and how she didnt want to go to her grandparents. What do you think

Oliver said...

I think this book deviil's arithmatic has started off a little bow, but I think it will probobly get better. What do you think the purpuse of starting in the modern time period and going back in time instead of starting in WW2? I think we will find out later though. why do you think the ather when Hannah went back in time made her just recovering from sickness? Maybe just maybe the people in the story would reconiz her acting different if she wasn't

Sam F said...

Well this is another school book, just like always boring! I mean I wish it could of explianed more things. Like I still dont understand the whole point of the festavle. Why does she go back in the past. Well those are just my opinions.

Oliver said...

as i said previosly I thought it started slow, but will probably get better

Oliver said...

Sam what school books are deffinetly not always boring

sam f said...

Ya i guess it may get better but I mean if i was sent back in time i would run out of the house and say u guys dont now me at all

Sam NImphie said...

hello, i was just going to talk about Devil's Arithmetic. This book seems very interesting so far. I thought it was interesting when the auther talked about the logic about dreams, like about her internal translator. It seems that whenever Hannah talks about her life it seems to fit with what Shmuel and Gitl believe about her. (i.e. she says she misses her family and Shmuel and Gitl think her parents died)It is funny when she actually says how it doesn't make any sense to be in her "dream." I am not entirely sure about her time-traveling but hopefully it will be revealed late. I think Hannah's goal for the book will to get back to her real family. I just thought I would share with you my thoughts about this book.

Oliver said...

I must aggree with that

sam said...

sam u might get in trouble for saying school books are boring

sam said...

sam u might get in trouble for saying school books are boring

sam f said...

ya parvanas journey BORING
Crispin BORING
so ya mostly boring

Oliver said...

both of those nice paragraph Sam N.

SAM said...

what do u think is going to happen later in the book

Sam N said...

and sam f, school books arn't always boring

sam f said...

Well sam n i dont like this book at all

Oliver said...

Sam I liked parvana's Journy just not the projects for it

Sam N said...

All sams please put your last initial in your comments

sam f said...

YES THEY ARE

sam f said...

YES THEY ARE

sam r said...

ok sam n what do you think is going to happen l8er in da book

Sam N said...

I think eventually Hannah will just accept where she is and play along with it.

sam f said...

I hate this book