Wednesday, May 26, 2010

Devil's Arithmetic Week 4

22 comments:

Sam Nimphie said said said...

Hello I finished my book and would like to talk about it. The book ended in a very mysterious way... It make you wonder about stuff like how she went through all those months and then turn up the excact second she went to the past! It makes no sense but it is very interesting. I kinda liked how her aunt Eva WAS Rivka and she had known Chaya. Thank you and please reply

sa,m F said...

I really thought the book was really sad especialy when I found out it was a true story. I also thought that it was really sad when she saved Rivca a.k.a Aunt Eva. I liked the ending that was good to!!

SAMUEL ERIC RALSTON said...

hey my name is Sam Ralston. I am almost done with the book. I really wana know what happens. Right now it is a big mistory . On if she is going to die. Does she die??? What happens at the end of the book??

sa,m f said...

SHE DIES!!!!

Oliver said...

I really thought the book had ending with how she dicided to go into the gas chamber and die to save her friend. It was kind of odd when Fayge ran out to die with Shmuel. I wonder why the auther made that happan. I also wonder why she made Hannah die and Yitzack escape. Post your comments on haw you liked it. use last anitial

SAMUEL ERIC RALSTON said... said...

the ending was good

Sam Nimphie answered Sam Ralston and said...

She gets chosen to go in the gas chamber, it goes black and she back in the present.

Oliver said...

she does die in a gas chamber she sacrafices her life for another

sa,m f said...

Ya the auther based it on a true story so of course some things that happen you wont like but you have to deal with it.

Sam Nimphie answered Oliver said...

Yeah thats what happened.

Oliver said...

ratings of the book people i will give mine after you post yours

samuelericralston said...

Overall this was a really good book

sa,m f said...

6/10

Sam Nimphie Posted his rating of the book......... said...

7/10

samsamralstonralston said...

***** stars

Oliver said...

sam r.

Oliver said...

okay i say 3/4 or 7.5/10

sa,m F said...

LOVED BLOGING thought it was a great expirement!!!!!!!

Sam Nimphie LIke the blogging very much......................... said...

I liked the blogging because it was fun instead of class and/or writing stuff.

SAM said...

I thought the blogging was a sufficunt was to discuss the book. Thanks Mrs. Smith for letting us do it. it was really fun

Anonymous said...

I really enjoyed this book i am glad i did not see any 2/10 or lower from you so at least you kind of liked it. Talk to you later!!!

Oliver said...

sarry I was trying to click thi shift key that was me.